Monday, April 17, 2006

Hypocrites!

"May his soul rest in peace" they shouted in unison. Did they really mean it?


On that fateful afternoon of 12th April, 2006, Karnataka lost one of its most revered and talented actors of the Kannada film industry - Dr.Rajkumar. Just as Kannadigas prepared to give the departed soul a tearful farewell and a deserving tribute, violence and cheap vandalism rocked the city. Buses were stoned, tyres burnt, mobs lathi-charged, lots of public property damaged and 6 people killed.

Contrary to what most groaners who were the victims of such public disruption claim, the ruckus created by the "fans" wasn't just because of the fact that the actor died a natural death.It was because his body was being shifted from one place to another like a sealed snail-mail. Fans who gathered outside his bungalow to have a final glimpse of the body had to run pillar to post, shifting no less than 5 venues! There's also a huge question mark lingering even to this day, over who created the ruckus at all. Rather than the fans, it seems more likely that it was an act done by the anti-social elements. Neglected by the government they live, in filthy, godforsaken areas, where education has no respect and lives have no value. They wait to take revenge, revenge against the government, revenge against the society, which have provided them nothing. Worst of all, they are supported by parties which are not in power, parties that are interested in gaining cheap political mileage out of the entire mournful episode. Karnataka's opposition party is believed to have bribed these anti-social elements and instigated them into committing acts of arson and vandalism, just to expose frailties in Kumaraswamy's administration and nail him by hook or crook.

It isn't just Bangalore that has been witness to such embarassing crowd behaviour. Bad crowd behaviour has been a known devil in the Indian society as a whole. The shameful vandalism witnessed in Bangalore was just one amongst a series of such nauseating crowd behaviour - The death of MGR in TN and NTR in AP witnessed vandalism akin to the one we saw on 12th April,2006. On a slightly unrelated note, it also rekindles memories of the Eden Gardens fiasco, where an unsportive crowd made it inevitable for India to hang her head in shame in front of a powerful West Indies team; Conrad Hunte was reported to have climbed the flagpole to save the West Indies flag, before fleeing the ground on foot. Unfortunately, there are very few Conrad Hunte’s in India and they stand vastly outnumbered by scores of people like you and me who just read and write about mob fury, discuss it, condemn it, complain endlessly about it and blame the system for all its loopholes. We are no doubt responsible citizens in so far as not indulging in such mobs is concerned. We are responsible citizens in so far as condemning such behaviour is concerned. BUT are we really responsible enough to go that extra mile to look beyond just our dutiful roles in the society and do something bigger to jolt atleast a few vandals into a greater level of sensibility and social responsibility?

Like Gururaj observes in his blog, whenever there is a socially impactful event/condition, we generally see people around us clustering into one of the 3 groups - the talkers, the indifferent and the doers. The same was the case with Dr.Raj's demise. I, for one, am ashamed to note that I (probably most of us) remained in the first of these groups. Is abstinence from mob violence the only contribution we can make as socially responsible citizens? Can't we do something more, even if it's just a small thing, towards preventing such an incident again? Even small acts of responsibility such as contribution of money and/or time and effort towards initiatives like education/rehabilitation of anti-social elements could make a big difference. The next time we say "May his soul rest in peace", let us really mean it!

9 Comments:

At 1:05 AM, Blogger Bhaskar Sree said...

This is exactly what i am talking about... indifference/justification.. Just b'cos some vandalism happened elsewhere, dont you justify the vandalism post Dr.Raj...

Shifting the body b/w 5 different places, not letting the mourners catch a glimpse of his body, .... are all just excuses. Wake up.. Do you know how many petrol bunks were looted enroute? Do you know how many IT companies/showrooms were destroyed? Take a ride along the Sankey road and the road to Windsor Manor.. look at Hyundai, Fiat showrooms.. look at all the windows of the buildings on that stretch. Look at Talisma tech...

Bhaskar

 
At 1:16 AM, Blogger anoop said...

When I started reading this post, I thought, Oh God another of those posts which is complaining about: how inefficient Bangalore police are, how bad the mob over here is.. etc.. But, the later half of the third paragh and the last paragh is where the post starts proving the point, which it was meant to..

I do like the Question being raised here: "Is it enough that we abstain from such acts of vandalism, or try to do something more, so that the vandals themselves cease to exist". The talkers and the doers.

If I decide to be a "Doer", Im still not sure what I need to do to improve the situation. Yes, you have given one of those solutions.. but, still..

P.S. thanks for providing the link for potnis blog, excellent writing style.

 
At 2:42 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

ah!

What is someone supposed to do in front of mob violence? And it is not just in India, remember the ruckus which English fans used to create after every football match.

Sometimes, you just need a strong hand. The police took these mornons lightly because they were supposedly mourning. They should all have been given a kick on their butts.

We in India have too much tolerance for mob violence.

 
At 9:49 AM, Blogger chutki said...

[Bhaskar]: >>This is exactly what i am talking about... indifference/justification.. Just b'cos some vandalism happened elsewhere, dont you justify the vandalism post Dr.Raj...

Nope, sir. Iamn't justifying the vandalism post Dr.Raj at all.It deserves to and is, being condemned.The point Iam trying to make is:
Bangalore per say, doesn't deserve to be condemned as badly as it is, because of the vandalism that tore apart the public propery in the city.If you're saying "Vandalism was terrible", yes sir, you're justified in syaing so.If you're saying "Look at what happened...I told you Bangalore is a sick place to be in", you need to take a look at whether things are blissfully better elsewhere.

[Anoop]:Adult anti-social elements are generally, though not always, incorrigible.The long hands of the law are probably the only ray of hope if something has to be done about them.If one wants to be a 'doer' the arena of anti-social kids offers a plethora of opportunities.Those kids who you generally see on the streets ragpicking or maybe smelling fevicol or doping are the ones who generally grow into anti-social elements coz they are increasingly getting distanced from the mainstream of the society.There are homes in Bangalore that rescue,shelter and try to re-integrate these kids and get them back on track during those formative years when something can actually be done about it.A doer can contribute in terms of money and/or time and effort in these homes.Iam currently working with a few of these homes.Get in touch with me if you're interested to be a doer.

I shall approach Potnis for referral royalty soon :)

[Confused]: >> What is someone supposed to do in front of mob violence?
Prevention is better than cure. Read the reply to Anoop, to know what you can do as preventive measures.

 
At 11:01 PM, Blogger Arjun Sharma said...

Oh, if this was bad, the post-MGR scenario was even worse, apparently. Rampant mobs destroyed everything in sight and toppled statues(and burnt effigies)of Karunanidhi(then, MGR's chief political rival). My parents were in Madras at the time and they heard some people say, apparently, "MGR is dead; why should Madras live?"

In face of such overwhelmingly compelling logic, there is little anyone can do.

 
At 11:13 AM, Blogger Raghu said...

Hey...
The dead body being shifted from one place to another place can be considered as a reason for the already shocked crowd to lose their temper....i agree to it... but i actually don't get the link of opposition party getting some anti social elements to create ruckus.... do u have any clear info abt this ? or is like .."i heard it from someone".. kind of information.... if so, then i guess a good writer like u shudn't base ur writings on rumours....

I agree with all ur remaining points....

 
At 10:59 PM, Blogger Sandy said...

Its really disappointing to see the ugly side of Bangalore :(

 
At 3:31 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

“Can't we do something more, even if it's just a small thing, towards preventing such an incident again?...”

I understand your concern about the problem but totally disagree with the solution.

Who is responsible for damages caused to Software companies?
It is clear that these anti social elements are encouraged by some local leaders. Why do they encourage? To gain more power. Why are they powerful first of all? Because they win in elections. Why do they win? Because, “those who think don’t vote and those who vote don’t think”!!!
How many software engineers in Bangalore have their names listed in voters list? How many of them cast vote?
What best Government can do in such situation? Check what our CM did right after these acts of violence - http://www.deccanherald.com/deccanherald/apr162006/state1917292006415.asp
http://www.deccanherald.com/deccanherald/Apr202006/state197582006419.asp
He is champion of this game!!

“They wait to take revenge, revenge against the government, revenge against the society, which have provided them nothing…..”
Any such act of vandalism, they will be benefited. They choose leaders. It is very difficult for CEO of a multi-million company to change a Government’s decision but handful of such people can!! They are the Government, they are the society!

Who is responsible for damages caused to Software companies? “Soft”ware Engineers!

Hey…my argument might be slightly exaggerated and not supported by statistics. But I hope you catch my point.:)

-P.Kalyan

 
At 5:28 PM, Blogger Apun Ka Desh said...

We must be one of the very few countries in the world where rampaging mobs is a regular reality.

What a shame.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home