Thursday, October 06, 2005

Closed Indian mind - does it let you live for yourself? - Part II

...continued from Part I

Finally my point: What’s factor X!?! Initially I thought it was an allusion to the kind of compulsion and pressure that our immediate society exerts on us, limiting the choices WE can exercise on OUR own lives. However, on deeper thought, Iam strongly convinced factor X is NOT that! It IS, on the other hand, a lack of self-confidence, a lack of mental strength of today’s Indian youth, to live life on their own terms, to decide for themselves and stick to it despite all odds. On one hand, the supposed hallmark of the Indian value system imbibed in most Indian youth right from their birth, screams out to them: “Don’t be selfish with your life. Live your life for the sake of others and not just for your own sake”. So they are tempted to let their immediate society pull the strings – moms dictate careers, dads dictate love-lives, friends dictate lifestyles, mothers in law dictate religious beliefs and even clothing! On the other hand, the influential breeze of western culture to which the youth are exposed through mass media and their friends’ circles, places a heavy accent on individualism and whispers to them “It’s YOUR life, the only one you’ve got. Live it the way YOU want it, not the way someone else wants you to live it”. Thanks to the two influences, a lot of directionless confused behaviour results and even passes off unnoticed, in the guise of the cleverly camouflaged term 'balanced individualism'. Balanced Individualism, as we may like to trumpet it, is by no means a positive sign. It is just a eunuch outcasted from the coterie of both class A people and class B people. Class A people are the highly individualistic class of people who want to make their own decisions, live their lives the way they want to, hold the reigns of their lives completely in their own hands and realize that just because parents, friends and relatives have showered them with love, it doesn’t mean that they can exercise undue influence in one's major decisions in life. Class B people on the other hand, are the ones for whom, keeping their near and dear ones satisfied, living by the society’s norms, swaying to the trends of the day in order to gain social acceptance, matter more than their own terms in life. It wouldn’t be wrong to say that the former class let their heart rule over their head, while the latter class of people do just the opposite. None of these classes, however, can be categorically stated to be superior to the other.

It is NOT wrong to be class A, it is NOT wrong to be class B either. After all, it is just about making a choice of which type one wants to be and being at peace with oneself about the choice one has made. However, the whole problem with most Indian youth is that they are so insecure, want so much of everything, need the eunuch called Balanced Individualism so much, that they neither firmly choose class A, nor firmly choose class B. If they ever do, they end up cribbing about losing out on either the social circle or on self-satisfaction as the case may be. The trend in India regarding the 2 classes, has been an interesting one too. The fairly orthodox Indians of the yester generations, were mostly of class B and the contemporary generation is of neither classes – it is in a transition phase, uncomfortably stuck between the two classes. It won’t be long before there is a huge shift and most of the Indian youth will be Class As. This latter transition will definitely be a welcome change and will be far more euphoric, not because class A is better but because there will atleast be a much-needed certainty in this critical decision of who controls one’s life to what extent.

I, for one, am surely interested in following the trend and checking out what difference it makes to the great Indian psyche.Maybe when it's finally a society filled with class A youth, a college student won't think twice about dropping out of a course he doesn't like and starting off a new enterprise...and maybe, there won't be anymore Vidya's and Meena's cribbing about we know what...and maybe,a die-hard travelling fan, much like today's foreign tourist, will just pack his bag and leave home one fine morning when he feels like travelling, with a few hundred bucks, a few pairs of clothes and nothing else - not even an idea of where his travel's gonna take him, return after a good travel and sit back n smile satisfactorily "Aah!THAT's what I wanted to do with my life" :)

Quote for the day:Ultimately, it isn't what choice you make that determines how happy you are.It's just how much you can be at peace with the consequences of your choice that really matters.

11 Comments:

At 12:24 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Nice one...
However, I tend to disagree that a change to Class A would be an "euphoric" transition. On the contrary, it may lead to wrong and terrible decisions, if the weight of taking independent decisions is thrust at a too early age.
But as you say at the end, it depends on how much peace you make with yourself once the decision is made, right or wrong.

 
At 5:47 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I knew u talk n talk but never thought so much ... nice to discover an EX oracle lite in bloggers world.

Just a comment I think most of us belongs to somewhere in between class A and Class B. Society and environment always influence us , conciously or unconciously , someway or other. May be some one is not influenced by the custom at all but he/she may well be influenced by Ayan Rand.

 
At 9:28 PM, Blogger Fundoo said...

Hmm.. that was *some* food for thought! Class A and class B theory... brilliantly put forward. Yes you bet, the transition phase it on! There is a heavy exodus of people from class B to class A as you rightly said. But then again, life at most times is in shades of gray, isn't it? May be what we call balanced individualism gives you best of both the worlds?! Guess it is one's perspective to see at it. A glass of water can be half empty to some and half full to others, hai na? :-)

But then I whole heartedly agree that decisions of one's OWN life must not be influenced by someone else's desires/whims/aspirations for sure! This will change... will change someday... how soon is the question! (I borrowed this line from your makkhi, machchhar and machhli post :p)

Awesome post!

 
At 11:33 PM, Blogger chutki said...

[Poxy]:Precisely Poxy!2 points that I wish to make here:
(1)When you say "it may lead to wrong and terrible decisions, if the weight of taking independent decisions is thrust at a too early age",it is a very judgemental opinion again.What seems wrong to you and me may seem perfectly the right thing to do to the decision maker in question.

(2)When I say "The shift to class A is euphoric", it isn't because of the freedom to decide, which may entail its own perils as you rightly pointed out.It is euphoric because of the certainty that comes with it.

 
At 5:00 AM, Blogger crusading against myself~! said...

hey another really great post..

comes close to one of the best i've read in really long i think...

and i agree quite completely with yr theory.. about the beauty of certainity of being an absolut rather than partly this and that...

they say the blend is the best.. as it contains the best of both worlds... but i've often wondered... if some blends contain the best of both.. some must even contain.. the worst of both!

 
At 1:57 PM, Blogger Jax said...

Nice posts. I agree with what you are saying. We are caught in a time-warp where we are neither in Class A nor in Class B. I have also noticed that people these days show an inclination to Class A before they get married and then they choose to take the beaten path and "settle down" in Class B.

I am sure the next generation will have less of such eunuchs!

 
At 3:43 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Another Ayn Rand in the making ;-)

 
At 5:37 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

one of the best summarizations of ayn rands book.. if you have written this without reading that book, hats off to you..

 
At 10:05 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Oh hell!! Another person to stereotype "today's youth" !! All we needed!!

Listen, no matter what philosophy you choose to believe or accept, individualism is a trait that is much prevalent. If a person needs to take a decision, and he/she is certain about it, he/she WILL take it. No amount of societal or familial pressure or emotional blackmail can change that. Men(and I use this with no intention of chauvinism. I just get tired of typing men/women everytime, for the sake of political correctness, when everyone knows men/women is what is meant) of seemingly no conviction have risen to take momentous decisions. Gandhiji sat on that Pietermaritzburg railway platform all night and took his momentous decision to fight back. Before this, he was what you might call a "Class B" individual. And he was in his youth too, then, one could say. On the other hand, we have so many "Class A" individuals, from nice families, free-thinking and liberal about issues such as career and marriage and what-and-all, following meekly in obvious careers, rather than boldly go where they haven't been before. Youth like Rahul Gandhi or Sachin Pilot. All right, admittedly, I don't know whether they WANTED political careers. But it does seem like they were pushed into it. And they let themselves be pushed.

Anyway, it doesn't matter what "class" of individuals you belong to. "The moment shall dictate the madness" is all I'm trying to say. (As an aside, I just made that up. Clever, huh?)

 
At 2:53 PM, Blogger chutki said...

[fb]:hehe now you know better.Hey!Iamn't influenced by Rand.I've never read any of her works, though I'd love to.The closest I got was when I picked up Fountainhead but here's a candid admission:I never got beyond 60 pages or so.I loved the book, rather whatever part of it I read, but I haven't managed to spare the kind of time it takes to complete it.Hope to go back to it very soon.

[Fun_da_mental]:Thanq sirjee.Hmmm the shift's coming,slowly but surely.

[Crusading against myself]:True, but no matter how necessary certainty is, life's almost never in black n white.It's generally in shades of grey, isn't it? :)

[jax]:hehehe nice point that you noticed.The fact that one is responsible not just for the well-being of oneself but also for the well-being of the spouse probably twists the psyche into retreating to the cosy proven-to-work comforts of a beaten-path corner.

[Anon]:Good but do refer what I've written above in reply to FB's comment.

[Anoop]:Then it's 'hats off to me' :)

[Arjun Sharma]:Oye kiddo!Individualism is a trait that's much prevalent?I don't blame you for saying so, considering how much of the world,you've seen.Iamn't contesting the fact that it isn't prevalent but I do insist it is forced into being dormant in MOST Indian youth due to societal pressure.In our generation, Gandhiji's are definitely far fewer in number than Rahul Gandhi's and Sachin Pilot's.The former number however are definitely larger than what they were in the past, which precisely is the shift iam talking about.

 
At 3:03 AM, Blogger Unknown said...

Nice blog. I happened to think on the same lines but with more philosophical perspective. So thought of adding my comments. Hope not wasting your space and time.

Taking (what appears to be) "class-A" decisions only satisfies our ego and hence if we take only class-A decisions life becomes "value less" or ultimately meaning less! Moreover class-A decisions are inconsistent.

Class-A is created not just from Western influence but from "education" which gives us confidence to think independently. But this confidence is not so strong that we always follow class-A. class-B is created out of our system of believes (which I refer as "values"). So the problem is "logic" vs. "values".

class-A and class-B actually does not exists! It arises because of (either or both) lack of our ability to think completely logically and/or lack of conviction to our values. This is the source of confusion. It is more in Indian youth as we are in between two generation of values(past) and logic(present).
We usually fail to see logic behind class-B decisions and fail to associate values (or meaning) to our class-A decisions. If we do so, then two classes cease to exist and things become clear and what is to be done becomes obvious.

One can't be happy as long as he/she can see two decisions - class-A and class-B.

I personally feel that we are slowly moving towards a point where logic & values (that is class-A and class-B, in fact science and religion!!) are getting combined!

 

Post a Comment

<< Home